Why Artificial Intelligence Can't Replace the Moral Significance of Humility

Embracing reliable interventions to cultivate humility.

In today's fast-paced, technology-driven world, the concept of humility seems to be fading away. With the rise of social media and the constant need for self-promotion, the once highly valued virtue of humility has been overshadowed. As Artificial Intelligence (AI) continues to advance and become a significant part of our lives, the question arises - can AI replace the moral significance of humility? In this post, we will explore the importance of humility and how it cannot be replicated by technology.

The Unraveling Virtue of Humility

Intellectual humility is a particular kind of humility that has to do with beliefs, ideas, or worldviews.¹ It is not only about religious beliefs. It shows up in social attitudes, political views, and areas of knowledge or expertise containing both internal and external-facing dimensions. Intellectual humility involves awareness and ownership of the limitations and biases in what you know and how you know it,² and, a willingness to revise views in light of evidence.³ Humility can also unlock authenticity. ⁴

Beyond what social science research identifies as intellectual humility, what was once a deeply interwoven in the fabric of human consciousness, the noble virtue of humility is showing signs of wear and tear. At its essence, humility represents a reserved perspective of one's own importance. It echoes in the echo of admitting our faults, in the actions we take to prioritize others before ourselves. Humility is a sibling of selflessness and sacrifice - characteristics that form the core of our humanity. Numerous spiritual, psychological, and sociological doctrines have praised the merits of humility. Yet, we find ourselves asking - is our fast-paced, self-centered world slowly eroding this virtue from our social tapestry?

We live in an era where bragging rights are earned through material success rather than moral virtues. The unending quest for achievements, the race to outdo each other, has left little room for the humble acceptance of our limitations and the magnanimity to put others' needs before ours. Interpersonally, we are forgetting how to keep our ego in check⁵ to present ideas in a modest and respectful manner. This areas of our humanity involves showing that we care more about learning and preserving relationships than being “right” or demonstrating superiority.

As we plunge deeper into this vortex of self-obsession, are we leaving behind the cornerstone of our humanity, humility? The impending question is, as we move farther away from this virtue, are we setting a dangerous precedent for the future generations to come?

This unraveling of humility is not just a cause for concern but a call to action. We are not merely observing a shift in our values but are participants in this change. The question we need to ask ourselves is - are we comfortable with the implications of this transition? The answer might just be the compass we need to navigate our way back to the path of humility.

The Influence of Social Media on Selflessness

We are currently experiencing a seismic shift in the way social media molds our perceptions of self and society. Social media, designed to connect us, has often veered us towards a road marked by self-aggrandizement and competition, eroding the sense of selflessness along the way. This new-age digital platform often brings out a need for validation, an urge to be liked, followed, and shared by others. And in this frantic race for digital approval, we risk losing sight of the intrinsic value of humility and selflessness.

A burgeoning groupthink mentality, fueled by social media, threatens the significance of individual virtues. It's not uncommon to see our feeds flooded with humblebrags and conspicuous acts of charity, aimed more at seeking public approval than exhibiting real humility. Instead of humble acknowledgments of our own shortcomings, we see boastful declarations of success, often embellished for the sake of social media optics. This shift isn't merely changing the way we interact, but also how we perceive ourselves and our virtues.

We're increasingly more invested in gaining acceptance and popularity than nurturing our ability to genuinely celebrate others' successes, be empathetic, and embrace selflessness. In this pursuit, the risk is that humility might become yet another performative act, stripped of its genuine sincerity, designed to garner more 'likes' than to contribute to personal growth and emotional evolution.

The irony is hard to miss. Social media, built to bring us closer, may actually be pulling us away from some of our most cherished human virtues, nurturing instead a culture that may leave no room for true humility and selflessness. The question, however, remains: Can we utilize these platforms in a way that celebrates humility and fosters selflessness, instead of undermining them? Especially in a cultural norm that rewards being right and punishes mistakes?⁶ As we move forward, finding this balance may be key to preserving the essence of our humanity in a world increasingly governed by 'likes' and 'follows'.

The Limitations of Artificial Intelligence in Reciprocating Humility

Artificial Intelligence has shown a profound capacity to replicate many human attributes. It mirrors emotional responses, forecasts behavior, and even exhibits a semblance of consciousness. However, when it comes to mirroring humility, AI hits a significant roadblock. The current design of AI lacks the ability to internalize self-reflection, self-sacrifice, and the sincere regard for others that are at the heart of authentic humility. While AI has become increasingly adept at performing tasks, solving complex problems, and presenting the illusion of 'understanding' us, it has yet to reach a level where it can genuinely comprehend or embody the ethical implications and depth of humility. It's a testament to the nuanced complexity of this human virtue and a stark reminder of the limitations of AI when it comes to replicating the full spectrum of human emotions and values. AI, as we know it, remains a machine - devoid of the ability to humble itself, incapable of the self-awareness required to understand and reciprocate humility in its truest sense. The question we need to ponder upon is - can AI, despite its exponential advancement, ever capture the full essence of human virtues like humility, or are some aspects of our humanity simply too intricate to be programmed into a machine?

AI can’t admit what it doesn’t know⁷ and seek to learn something new the way a person does. As Mark Twain captures this sentiment in his words, “I’m in favor of progress; it’s change I don’t like.”

Is Humility Becoming Extinct?

As we immerse ourselves deeper into an increasingly digitized world, we must contemplate: are we witnessing the demise of open mindedness, curiosity, and realistic, and teachable aspects of character? Could it be that our descendants will adapt to a life devoid of genuine humility, swapping it instead for a masked version paraded around for social media acceptance? It's a bleak thought, considering our forebears placed great importance on this virtue, noting its significant role in shaping civil society and fostering sincere relationships. Can we afford to stand by and watch the central parts of humility — forgiveness, personal growth, and acceptance — become a casualty in this digital revolution?

In our era, where social media fuels egocentrism and AI seems to be taking over the realms of human interaction, we need to ensure that we aren't letting the greater tolerance toward people with whom we disagree with fall by the wayside.⁸ Are we unknowingly nurturing an environment where humility is no longer valued but discarded? Are we, in essence, allowing our actions and digital habits to push humility to the brink of extinction?

We must consider the dire consequences of such a loss. Without humility, we risk fostering a culture where self-importance overshadows empathy, and individual success becomes more important than collective well-being. In such a society, we may end up promoting vanity over virtue, narcissism over selflessness, and isolation over unity.

As we continue to engage with evolving technology and digital platforms, let us remember to pause, reflect, and question - are we doing enough to preserve humility in our social and personal spheres, or are we inadvertently pushing it towards obsolescence? The answer to these questions might be more crucial to our emotional evolution and societal fabric than we might presume.

The Way Forward: Reviving Humility in a Digital Age

Researchers are working hard to validate effective ways to cultivate intellectual humility.⁹ Scholars are engaging in discussions and exploring the role of enhancing listening. Others are testing educational programs while other interventions are exploring different types of feedback to diverse social networks to enhance intellectual humility. In this work, humility can be cultivated.¹⁰

Navigating our way forward in this digital era calls for a resolute commitment to revive the fading virtue of humility. It is essential to understand that humility, far from being a symbol of meekness, is a reflection of strength, courage, and genuine character. Our academic institutions must aim to instill in students not just high IQs but also high emotional intelligence. Emphasizing the importance of virtues like humility, selflessness, and empathy should be paramount in shaping young minds.

In parallel, we should exercise responsible use of AI. Our reliance on this technology should never overshadow the essence of human consciousness and the intricate array of emotions that define us. We must maintain a clear demarcation between human sentiments and machine intelligence, and ensure we do not lose ourselves in the mirage of technological advancement.

In essence, the road to reviving humility demands that we put the virtue into daily practice. We must be ready to celebrate the successes of others, admit our mistakes, acknowledge our limitations, and put the needs of others before our own. It requires embracing a mindset that values the collective good over individual achievements. Only then can we successfully resist the cultural tide pulling us towards self-centeredness and ensure that humility, in its truest sense, does not merely survive but thrives in the digital age.

Our mission to revive humility should be pursued with as much fervor as we pursue technological advancements. In doing so, we may just discover that the virtues we are struggling to hold onto, such as humility and selflessness, are the very anchors we need to keep us grounded in this constantly evolving digital landscape. Let us remember to not just live in the age of AI, but to thrive with humility as our guiding star.

1. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167217697695

2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191886917307286?via%3Dihub

3. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223891.2015.1068174

4. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0749597817308890?via%3Dihub

5. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/009164711404200103

6. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1948550609355719

7. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191886916301489?via%3Dihub

8. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17439760.2015.1037861

9. https://www.intellectualhumilityscience.com

10. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/009164711404200111